AFIBest AFI Albums Ranked

AFI

exclaim

6.0

“It's hard to shake off singer Davey Havok's sterile lyrics, especially when many of the choruses lean heavily on his bold, operatic delivery yet are somewhat squandered on half-cocked one-liners.”

AFI (The Blood Album)

pitchfork

5.0

“The timing couldn’t be better for AFI’s triumphant comeback; instead, they just sorta came back. This new LP works a “back to basics” operating principle, but it’s a “basics” that doesn’t serve them.”

Burials

fantano

2.0

“AFI's Burials is the latest in a long string of uninteresting records from this California band.”

Decemberunderground (Bonus Track Version)

Ryan1Nunez

6.5

“There are certain albums that instantly take you back to a specific moment in your life, and Decemberunderground is one of those records for me. I was a teenager when it came out in 2006, and I still remember hearing “Miss Murder” everywhere. Like a lot of people my age, that song was my introduction to AFI, but the deeper I got into the album, the more I realized there was so much more beneath the hit single. Looking back, this album perfectly captured that mid-2000s alternative scene. It was dark, dramatic, emotional, and unapologetically theatrical. Davey Havok’s vocals balanced vulnerability with intensity, while Jade Puget’s guitar work and the atmospheric production gave the record a haunting quality that stood out from everything else I was listening to back then. “Love Like Winter” remains one of the most beautiful songs AFI has ever written, and tracks like “The Missing Frame,” “Summer Shudder,” “The Killing Lights,” and “Endlessly, She Said” have only gotten better with age. Even after all these years, they still carry the same emotional weight they did when I first heard them as a teenager. I understand why this album divided longtime fans. It moved further away from AFI’s punk roots and leaned into a more polished, alternative rock sound. But that’s exactly what makes it special to me. The band wasn’t afraid to evolve, and instead of chasing what had already worked, they created something that felt ambitious, cinematic, and uniquely theirs. Revisiting Decemberunderground now is a reminder of how music can become part of your own story. It brings back memories of late-night drives, burned CDs, and discovering artists that helped shape my musical taste. It’s an album that defined a chapter of my teenage years, and every listen feels like opening a time capsule. Nearly two decades later, Decemberunderground still sounds bold, emotional, and unmistakably AFI. It may not be everyone’s favorite in their catalog, but for those of us who grew up with it, it’s more than just an album, it’s a soundtrack to adolescence that never really lost its magic.”