Charlie PuthBest Charlie Puth Albums Ranked

CHARLIE

rollingstone

8.0

“On Charlie Puth's terrific, cohesive third studio album, the man with the perfect pitch proves he’s got the perfect formula for a great pop record too”

CHARLIE

thelineofbestfit

8.0

“CHARLIE delivers some of Charlie Puth’s most authentic work to date”

Whatever's Clever!

pastemagazine

7.5

“Puth’s fourth album mollifies his anxious excitement around imminent domesticity through the lush, soothing, dad-core soundscape of late ‘80s/early ‘90s pop and soft rock.”

Voicenotes

nme

6.0

““Hate me or love me/that’s just the way I am” poster boy Charlie Puth croons on the opener to his second album ‘Voicenotes’. A clichéd sentiment, but one that rings true for the noveau-prince of pop. Cutting his teeth as a YouTube sensation and a protégé of Ellen DeGeneres (back in 2011 she signed him to her label after seeing him cover Adele), in 2015 Puth shot to the A List with his feature on t”

Nine Track Mind

pitchfork

2.5

“The 24-year-old Berklee College of Music graduate and former YouTube star Charlie Puth has already had three top 40 singles, all since last February: The Meghan Trainor duet "Marvin Gaye", "See You Again" featuring Wiz Khalifa, and "One Call Away," an ocean of syrup that sounds exactly like "See You Again" and is the first song on Puth's debut LP.”

Whatever's Clever!

Ryan1Nunez

7.4

“Whatever’s Clever! by Charlie Puth is one of those albums that really hits if you’re tuned into the details. It is the kind of project where the production alone keeps you coming back. As a fan, it’s hard not to admire how clean and intentional everything sounds. The mixes are crisp, the masters feel warm but polished, and every little sonic choice feels like it was obsessed over in the best way. What stands out most, though, is how that technical precision doesn’t come at the expense of emotion. Charlie’s songwriting here feels open and surprisingly vulnerable, like he’s letting you peek behind the curtain more than usual. There’s a self-awareness in the lyrics that makes the album feel personal without losing its mainstream appeal. The collaborations also elevate the project nicely and none of them feel thrown in for streams or hype. Instead, they blend naturally into the album’s sound, adding texture and perspective without overshadowing Charlie’s voice or vision. Overall, Whatever’s Clever! lands a strong album. It’s a producer’s album at heart, but one that still knows how to feel something…balancing technical brilliance with genuine emotional weight Fave Tracks: Home, Love In Exile, Beat Yourself Up, New Jersey, & I Used To Be Cringe”

Voicenotes

Ryan1Nunez

6.2

“I’ll be honest…before Voicenotes, I didn’t fully get the hype around Charlie Puth. The radio hits were catchy, sure, but they didn’t convince me I needed to sit through a full album. Voicenotes is what changed that. This record feels like Charlie stepping into his producer bag for real. The ‘80s-inspired grooves, the tight basslines, the glossy synths and it’s clear he’s obsessed with the craft. Songs like “Attention” and “How Long” (still elite pop records) showcase how sharp his ear is for melody and rhythm. You can hear the musicality in every layer, and as a music fan, that attention to detail won me over. That said, not every track hits equally hard. A few songs blend together in the middle, and emotionally it doesn’t always go as deep as it could. Sometimes the vibe carries more weight than the storytelling. Still, Voicenotes turned me from a casual listener into someone who actually pays attention when Charlie drops. It’s sleek, funky pop with real musicianship behind it — not perfect, but strong enough to convert me.”

Nine Track Mind Deluxe

Ryan1Nunez

7.1

“There’s something quietly compelling about Charlie Puth’s debut. It is polished, but undeniably heartfelt. You can hear him chasing the perfect pop formula in real time, blending smooth piano lines, layered harmonies, and that crisp, almost meticulous production style that would later become his signature. While the album leans heavily into mid-tempo ballads and radio-friendly structures, it never feels hollow. The melodies stick, the vocals are consistently strong, and there’s a sincerity in the writing that gives the record its emotional weight. Even when it plays things a bit too clean or predictable, there’s enough charm to keep you invested. It may not fully capture the artistic confidence he’d later show, but Nine Track Mind stands as a solid introduction—an album that hints at his potential while still finding its footing.”

CHARLIE

Ryan1Nunez

7.3

“With Charlie, Charlie Puth comes full circle, blending the polished pop hooks we know him for with a more personal, introspective side. As a fan, it’s exciting to hear him leaning into his own sound instead of chasing trends. The production is tight, the melodies are catchy, and his voice carries more warmth and nuance than ever. There are standout tracks that feel instantly classic in his catalog, but a few moments drag a bit, making the album feel slightly uneven. Still, the honesty and charm shine through, and it’s clear he’s growing as both a songwriter and performer. For anyone who’s followed him from the start, Charlie is a satisfying listen that reinforces why he deserves his spot in modern pop.”

Nine Track Mind

rjchristopher27

3.9

“Is this album great? No. Does it have redeeming qualities? In my opinion, yes. This album establishes Charlie as a singer, songwriter, producer in an intriguing way. While a lot of the record is immemorable at best, it certainly shows his potential and foreshadows his mature successor. Favs: Dangerously, We Don’t Talk Anymore, My Gospel, Up All Night, Suffer Meh: Marvin Gaye, Then There’s You, As You Are, Some Type of Love”

CHARLIE

rjchristopher27

4.1

“It’s such a shame that the production on this album is mostly bad, since I really do like a lot of its songs. The vocals are processed to oblivion and the beats are super derivative. There are a few highlights that I go back to, but its flaws are too blaring to ignore. Favs: Smells Like Me, Tears On My Piano, I Don’t Think That I Like Her, No More Drama Not good: Loser, When You’re Sad I’m Sad”

Voicenotes

rjchristopher27

8.0

“This album does not get the respect it deserves. Say what you want about Charlie now, but this was him at his best. A genuinely great pop album with a 90’s flare, the production excites and the vocals float over top. This is one of my favorites in the contemporary pop genre. Favs: all”

Whatever's Clever!

MusicLover1969

6.5

“A decent easy listening album from Charlie Puth that finds its footing midway and ultimately finds out what kind of album it’s wanting to be.”