Foo FightersBest Foo Fighters Albums Ranked

But Here We Are

nme

10

“Grohl and the gang work through their grief”

But Here We Are

consequence

9.1

“It’s a bit of cruel irony that in the face of so much adversity, the band has somehow managed to helm their most creative and compelling album in over 20 years. It may be hard for the band to recognize it, but believe it or not, Foo Fighters are learning to live again.”

Wasting Light

consequence

9.0

“Dave Grohl delivers one of the strongest outings in his band's storied career”

Your Favorite Toy

thelineofbestfit

8.0

“Foo Fighters embrace the frenzy on Your Favorite Toy”

But Here We Are

fantano

8.0

“A powerful set of songs from Dave Grohl and company.”

But Here We Are

rollingstone

8.0

“But Here We Are, the band's first album since the loss of drummer Taylor Hawkins, depicts grief in immediate terms”

Your Favorite Toy

Ryan1Nunez

6.5

“There’s something comforting about coming back to Your Favorite Toy. It hits that familiar Foo Fighters groove that I’ve been hooked on since my high school days. As someone who grew up on both their catalog and classic rock staples, you can feel those roots baked into the DNA here: big guitars, punchy hooks, and that raw, no-frills energy. That said, it doesn’t quite reach the heights of their best work. Some tracks blur together, and a few choruses don’t hit as hard as you’d hope. But even at its most uneven, there’s still enough grit and heart to keep me locked in. It’s the kind of album that reminds you why you became a fan in the first place..even if it doesn’t fully evolve the sound. A solid, if slightly safe, addition to their legacy.”