Lucy DacusBest Lucy Dacus Albums Ranked

Home Video

rollingstone

9.0

“One of the best young songwriters around delivers the best LP of her career”

Historian

thelineofbestfit

9.0

“Lucy Dacus's second outing is a monolith of American songwriting”

2019

pastemagazine

8.5

“Can we make her birthday a national holiday now?”

Historian

pitchfork

8.1

“On her second album, the Virginia songwriter doesn’t merely reckon with loss; she tells a story about the way people carry each other through time.”

Forever Is A Feeling

pastemagazine

8.0

“The boygenius singer tries a more expansive musical approach, and gets more specific in her lyrics on her first solo album in four years.”

Forever Is A Feeling

rollingstone

8.0

“The indie-rock troubadour's fourth album, Forever Is a Feeling, trades coming-of-age storytelling for adult-specific love songs”

Forever Is a Feeling

Ryan1Nunez

6.8

“Forever Is A Feeling is a tender, slow-burning track that captures everything we love about Lucy Dacus—honest, emotionally raw storytelling wrapped in dreamy, understated production. Her voice feels like a warm memory, and the lyrics cut deep in that quiet, reflective way she’s known for. The song floats with a kind of nostalgic beauty, building gently but never quite exploding, which is both its strength and slight limitation. While it may not be the most immediately gripping song in her discography, it lingers with you long after it’s over—like a feeling you can’t quite shake. It’s a beautiful listen, especially if you’re in the mood to feel something soft and real. Not her boldest move, but definitely one that reminds us of her gift for subtle emotional storytelling”