PinegroveBest Pinegrove Albums Ranked

Marigold

thelineofbestfit

9.0

“Pinegrove attempt to reckon with their recent past on new LP Marigold”

Marigold

pastemagazine

8.1

“If you’re willing to hear them out, it’s their best record since Cardinal”

Everything So Far

thelineofbestfit

8.0

“Everything So Far tells the story of how Pinegrove got here”

Cardinal

pitchfork

8.0

“Montclair, N.J. band Pinegrove's debut LP Cardinal recalls some of the most consistently likeable rock bands of the past 20 years in their most easygoing phases: There’s the rootsy shamble of early Wilco, the wiggly guitar solos and general guilelessness of pre-prog Built to Spill. But beneath the amiable surface is an intense work about one of the most important things imaginable: how to make our friendships really matter.”

Cardinal

exclaim

8.0

“The emotionally charged Cardinal begins with wistful twang and the all-too-common existential dilemma of the young-but-swiftly-aging: the falling away of a past that was once forever. On "Old Friends," singer Evan Hall drawls, "I should call my parents when I think of them / Should tell my friends when I love them."   The Montclair, New Jersey's band's sound — off-the-cuff, loose heart-on-sleeve i”

11:11

pastemagazine

7.8

“When we last heard from Pinegrove’s Evan Stephens Hall, he was working through some very public personal stuff and trying to look to the future on his band’s pretty and introspective 2020 album, Marigold. “Is it so wrong?” he sang on “No Drugs,” the album’s third track. “I wanna feel good.” Two years later, Hall seems to have found his way there, even as the world has gone to shit. On Pinegrove’”