The Lonely IslandBest The Lonely Island Albums Ranked

Incredibad

pitchfork

7.7

“The best comedy is inherently nerdy, and the best music is (usually) pretty cool. So part of me wants to apologize for racking up more plays from the Lonely Island's *Incredibad* than any other album this year. I feel like a nerd. But I think the Lonely Island have found a populist way to elicit the same nerd thrills one would get from the best sketches from "The State" or "Upright Citizens Brigad”

The Wack Album

pitchfork

7.1

“The latest goofball pop send-up from Andy Samberg, Jorma Taccone, and Akiva Schaffer has guests including Robyn, Pharrell, Kendrick Lamar, Solange, Hugh Jackman, Lady Gaga, and more.”

Turtleneck & Chain

pitchfork

7.1

“What started as "Saturday Night Live" spoofs has now made Andy Samberg & co. into pop stars. Justin Timberlake, Rihanna, and Nicki Minaj guest.”

Turtleneck & Chain

rollingstone

7.0

“Five years since "Dick in a Box" forever changed our idea of dicks, boxes and Justin Timberlake, SNL’s pop-parody trio show no sign of running out of impossibly brilliant half-jokes. Their consistently great second disc combines songs you’ve YouTubed to death ("I Just Had Sex," "Motherlover") with top-shelf new material featuring good sports from Michael […]”

Turtleneck & Chain

nme

4.0

“If the Jackass boys can play with 3D diarrhoea as they push 40, why shouldn’t The Lonely Island continue their frat-isms into middle age? The Saturday Night Live trio pick up where they left off with 2009’s ‘Incredibad’, spoofing hip-hop and R&B with Rihanna, Snoop Dogg, JT et al garnering slices of self-deprecation kudos. Alas, parodying Auto-Tuned-to-hell R&B is largely pointless due to the rid”