Albums
Warnings / Promises
2005
Genre: Rock
Release Date: 2005
By Jason Crock
Reviewed April 27, 2005
Idlewild follow their European commercial breakthrough The Remote Part with this more defanged, sedate effort.
Idlewild's European fans have probably made peace with the fact they've moved from cult favorite to consistent hitmakers since the success of 2002's . is a step in the same direction, the work of a polished radio-ready rock band, and if I had to sum it up in a word, it'd be "comfortable": Comfortable in writing calculated hits like "Love Steals Us From Loneliness" or "I Understand It"; comfortable filling an arena with songs like "I Want a Warning"; comfortable with the R.E.M comparisons that have followed them throughout their career-- on "Not Just Sometimes But Always" Roddy Woomble is a dead ringer for Michael Stipe.